Home
downtown liverpool JULY 2005 ARCHIVE

CITY

 

Downtown creatives take a spin
Two downtown initiatives are inviting folk to join in their activities. Chinapool launch their 'Chinese painted boats' project this Sunday 10.30. Meet at the pierhead in front of the cunard building. The Unicorn will lead the way to the ferry. The ferry leaves at 11.00am prompt. Returns at 12.00 noon.

A marquee will be on site so bring a picnic!
Paintings by chinese artists will be on view. Workshops by Cathy Woo and Xia Lu will be in the marquee after the launch - All welcome


The mighty, majestic Mersey brought our Chinese community to Liverpool

Meanwhile, ace home from home for creatives, 3345 have an incredibly rich series of music and creative events every Thursday night, go to web for details of the latest acts.

A particularly popular series was the 'Acoustica' sets and the 3345 team want to get them going again. If you are interested in performing at Tom's place then email-Tom

The trials and tribulations of technology!
Regular downtowners will no doubt have noticed that we have not quite been up to our usual high standard, with regards to getting you fresh downtown info as soon as we hear, this week. We have been suffering from a technological version of the wobbly's we're afraid!

And what a week it's been! We've had stuff about trees, companies going bust and others slagging our 'lousy retail offer', to say nothing about yet more bizarre skyscraperaphobia and the usual, inevitable, depressing, low grade, counter productive, petty political grandstanding ...we wonder what the dailies will make of it?

Excellent downtown coverage in the Daily Post and Echo as usual - so go to our icliverpool link below and check out the stories.

We think we have cracked the main problem now so thanks (again) for bearing with us - we will put together a summary of the best of last weeks downtown news in a special page on Monday.

Too many obsessives and not enough Chieftans?
Be sure to get along to the public exhibition of the super cool development proposed for the car park on Skelhorn St and show your support?


Planners do not want this - the question should be, why do we still want their advice?

Plans can be seen at the Empire Theatre's atrium next Wednesday and Thursday (27th & 28th) between 11a.m & 7p.m

Look after the pennies
Downtown based company, Medicash, are planning a major expansion ..yet another example of little acorns being much more valuable to our urban economy than those big, bloated 'treats' that inward investment imposes.

Sad news however that Wade Smith is to close down ...helped on the way by LCC's obsession with multiples at the expense of metropolitan commerce? We have warned about relying on inward investment rather than metro wealth creation ..some forecasts look bad ..let's keep our fingers crossed!

That's the way to do it
Great stuff about that scouse youngster setting up an airline ...enterprise, not a subsidised hand out is the way in which the city will be restored.

Not everybody has to set up an airline though (though someone should take advantage of the massive profit to be made linking the Pool with NYC) ...small stuff like this new website, 'an independent guide to 2008' is as important...or what about these?


Sadie, with Nan, June, helping to entertain downtown shoppers

We came across some Scouse super talents of the future from The Harlequin Stage School providing culture and entertainment in downtown Church St as well as helping to build up their business. For more info call Dean on 287 0947

Just what we want to hear, the city's folk taking the reins up for themselves!

Not In Our Name
Even the most casual observer will have noticed the steady tide of letters in the local press recently, all from ordinary people bemoaning the critical grumblings of our planning officers towards new buildings (read 'investment') and the general depressing -and mistaken -attitude that somehow this city needs to be 'protected' from the Modern.

unity liverpool
Unity Buildings, Liverpool
reproduced by permission
with thanks to webbaviation

The above development being one of the few, high-quality, large scale designs to slip through the Planners net.

But why don't they pop down to Liverpool Vision and see what even the children have to say about the attitude to tall buildings, in the current (and wonderful) exhibition of schoolwork?

Culture News
The Culture Company have at last published their new website - a BIG improvement and which might now at least give us something to cheer about from Millennium House!

The 'X' factor?
Government funding has been agreed for two major downtown projects - a new museum of Liverpool on Mann island and a canal link between the North and South docks.

3xn mann island
credit: 3xn

Watch as costs escalate as, unlike the case with the Cloud, any extra burden will be carried by downtowners.

CABE has also just published its Design Review of the proposed Museum of Liverpool which makes interesting reading:

'We are also pleased to note that the scale of the building has been reduced in response to our comments and a review of the brief by the client'

Why must the scale of the building be reduced?! How will they fit it all in?

Date for your Diaries
Urban Forum's Annual Conference will be held at The Adelphi Hotel, Liverpool on 6/7 December 2005.

Downtown Lingchi?
When leading economists suggest a wake-up call for the city's attitude to parking - can we echo this by reminding our city (mothers and) fathers that the death of cities is usually not suicide but rather due to a thousand cuts..

A HUB of downtown youth culture
Don't forget to get downtown this weekend to see what young downtowners get up to. Downtown is for youth, exploration, and all sorts of undercurrents, detached from the mainstream .. and certainly Millennium House! Full details of times and venues.


Bunny Hopping in Derby Sq

There are kids doing 'HUB' type stuff year-round ...but beyond the festival they usually get stick!

Take a look at this interesting little piece about how urban cultures are international, multi cultural but also blended with the locale. Also this article on Hip Hop and Rap in Europe.

The Alley Alley O
The fabulous Crystal Symphony cruise liner docked in the Mersey today [Thursday 14th] at 5am, and departs this evening at 10pm.

crystal symphony
Crystal Symphony berthed in Mersey

You can get a feel of what it's like coming up the river by taking a look at the 'bridgecam'. Don't forget to just take 10 mins out of your day to go to the Pier Head and see the real thing though! And if you're looking at this site from on board - WELCOME, drop us an email and we'll post it online.

Ivory Towers
Two stories that we have covered before were highlighted this week. Welcome news that downtown's to get its first top class hotel in decades was
announced formally this week with the conversion of the former Conservative Club [Municipal Annexe building] in Dale Street, whilst another 'hotel story' just up the road took a nasty turn.


Royal Insurance Building

News that English Heritage has added the grade II* listed Royal Insurance Building in North John St to the Buildings at Risk register.

Will we end up with a 'Cassartelli' scenario when obsessives wring their hands after the original structure falls down after years and years of inteference in every proposal that could have saved the original? And will the former ABC Cinema on Lime Street also fall foul? Oh and the Wellington Rooms on Mount Pleasant? [etc. etc...]


Give a dog a bad name
Never having given too much store to the ramblings of corporate bores and provincial no-marks we were, naturally, not invited along to the CBI's 'North West' bash at downtown St George's Hall Wednesday night.

This instinct has been largely preserved once we had reports of the wise words of Digby Jones. Amongst the better ones was one about 'regional passion not allowing money to be lost to host the Olympics' - we can only assume he came across a New Labour leaflet floating around the square mile somewhere!!

Olympic Pique?
After all the shenanigans over yesterday's selection of 2012's venue for the Olympic games - we thought that super sexy Singapore came out best ... elegant, vibrant, non-grasping.

Perhaps Liverpool should bid to be the host of the next decision-making session?

Congratulations to London, now let's see if the guff about 'everyone in the UK benefiting' lives beyond the win?!! We suppose it knocks any any hope of the nationals now helping the
little celebrations taking place in 07/08?

Notable by Our Absence (no. 692)
Yet again a sore reminder of the catching up Liverpool needs to do in order to creep into the mainstream of urban design talk in the UK at the moment. John Sorrell, chief of design watchdog CABE speaking at the RIBA conference in Bristol this week - and unable to mention Liverpool! [link]

Mind the Gap
BBC-watchers are invited to submit a picture or two of the city to the Picture of Britain gallery, because few people seem to have bothered from either
the public or the BBC. [Incidentally, Tate was the Liverpool sugar company that provided the profits and donations for the art gallery that BBC has of course partnered with for this programme].

Liverpool was also 'cut out' of the BBC version of the Natural History of Britain too.. as well as the Battle of the Atlantic series last year and the latest BBC weathermap etc. etc. etc. ...

No Liverpool in BBCland.

Closer to Home Please
We mentioned earlier this week the fear that the Canning House Police HQ may be on the move out of downtown. News now that the wonderful Alder Hey Children's Hospital may not be moving to an adjacent site but options for alternative sites -including Huyton -are being considered. Please avoid.

Clatterbridge over on the Wirral is a good example of an excellent hospital, with great staff and patient care, in leafy countryside but a nightmare to get to for staff, and visitors, and patients.

Glad to say that the NHS has recently shown its committment to downtown..


No.1 Arthouse Square

..by placing its Primary Care Trust in this funky new building next to FACT! Good news.

Beating a Path(finder)
Many firms are now coming to Liverpool to help develop new social housing. Good to see then that firms like PTE Architects and URBED are in the city. Maybe they will snatch work from some (we regret) local firms that built the type of appalling, low density, anti-city [read 'high crime'?] cul-de sacs in the 80's and 90s. You know who you are!

Magnetic Attraction
News that the UK govt is considering a £16bn Maglev supertrain linking North and South should be welcomed. But not wishing to put the dampeners on it - the evidence of what has happened to rail services out of Lime Street station in the past 18mths should kill any optimism of the likelihood of a Maglev 'spur' into Liverpool.

We will of course have to commute to the regional 'capital' of Manchester by pack horse to pick it up. Place your bets now on politicos saying '..the economic case for extending the Maglev to Liverpool is regretably not justified..' in 15 years time...

It's all about perceptions
Substance over style, stuff over bluff,
Vision rather than vague aspirations.
News of a 'major redevelopment' of the
Woodside area of the Mersey, could take lessons from this piece from Brooklyn, whilst a host of strategies
in downtown Liverpool, from the Paradise project to the Capital of Culture agenda could be enlightened
by this one from downtown Hamburg.


NYNY courtesy: NYC & Company

Think big, aim high and you may just get somewhere - where did we hear that phrase 'make no little plans' in relation to Liverpool's ambitions?

When in Rome?
News from the Eternal City that even they have decided that ripping UP cobbled streets is the only way to protect the adjacent crumbling buildings and keep the metropolis on the move.


Load of Cobble[r]s

In Liverpool meanwhile, we're busily putting them back in!

Now THERE'S a heritage site
We hope you watched Sunday's BBC programme 'Coast' Liverpool's downtown World Heritage Site, as should have been gets a profile in a later episode - great stuff.


Thankfully, 'heritage' is about more than just buildings

As heritage block salvaging old buildings
English Heritage have been involved in determining what is most suitable for the former ABC Cinema on Lime St. LFC star Jamie Carragher is the latest to come up with plans to save and restore the building ...let's see what happens there. Previous plans have stalled because of obstinacy in adapting the building - meanwhile, this grand old cinema is slowly disintegrating.

The road to oblivion is couched in gobbledygook
Really interesting revelations as to just how far off-beam our city's planning has become.

Planning chiefs state, with regards to the Chieftain proposals for a new 32 storey tower near Lime Street outlined below,

"The proposed tower has no clear logical connection to the immediate buildings and appears to dominate the local townscape"

Followed by the usual nugget

"It would also have a negative impact on the adjoining area and World Heritage Site"

What the hell do these mean?!! .. more importantly should this type of nonsense dictate what function downtown takes on? That's just for starters. Give us strength...


Clashes with the adjacent architecture? Why was this selected as a tall building zone? Where's the principle?

For more details see icliverpool

Talking of taste
We hope all who could went along to support the Chieftan tower proposal? We would ask people to keep at the front of their thoughts, when reading the 'objections' and statements on 'taste' and 'suitability' of buildings by those officers recommendation is to refuse this tower a few pointers.

What they have in mind as a 'suitable' building for that site would be much more like Commutation Plaza than would be healthy (they where given free reign to design the ultimate building with that)

There are masses of contradictions and a huge U-turn is planned to change tack and recommend the Public sector backed replacement for Concourse House.

Their choices are being taken from a single aspect, which even in the best of circumstances is never a healthy approach.


The 'perfect type of building for downtown', as envisioned by those against tall buildings and modern architecture

They do not want a dynamic, forward looking (in both respects) commercially successful city - they want a rendition of a previous city that was wrecked in WWII and finished off in the 60s'

They are really quite, quite irrelevant - but they hold all the cards right now - which raises fundamental issues. What do most right minded people think?

A taste of where we are headed
can be gleaned from this article in the Scotsman about Edinburgh's heritage community's efforts to stifle what's goes on there ..and we can hardly call current development in that city 'rad'!

And there's more!
EH have finally come out of the closet today with regards to the Ballymore/Merepark proposal for Central Station. One objection is that it will 'soar' above the adjacent buildings. Isn't that what ALL tall buildings do? The Liver Bdg and Anglican cathedral do just that - it's part of what makes them so impressive ...they create an impression.

This weeks events have now proven beyond doubt that our planning committee have been lied to all along by certain groups about the real intentions of the raft of restrictive codes in place or being crafted as we have said all along.

They are against any tall building ..in principle, they would just be shown as the excessive and irrelevant zealots that they are if they came out and said it. Please members of the committee, bear this in mind?

 


DOWNTOWN

 

Arias on the telly
The next broadcast on the BBC's big downtown telly takes place on 30th. La Boheme kicks of at 7.30 p.m, though you wouldn't know it from looking at the BBC website! Elliot St ..you can't miss it.

More, more, more
A recent report highlights that even though many city centre populations are booming, there is still a large way to go to compare to the likes of NYC and Barcelona. Lends the lie to recent pronouncements in Liverpool that we are getting too many flats.

Liverpool's downtown population is greater than every other English city to, it established ..as we highlighted early last year.

Better late than never we suppose
LCC have placed an advert for a strategic highways professional to oversee downtown's 'Big Dig', 18 months after it started.


Two signs now - will they make up for ineptness?


Taking a deserved break - the work goes on, day in, day out!

We support the 'Big Dig' and have echoed calls for patience and a little lateral thinking from downtown entrepreneurs to overcome the unavoidable issues it will cause. The keyword here though is unavoidable ...shouldn't that job have been the first one put into place?

Downtown's Garment District tells a sorry tale
All of our warnings about heritage obsession, on this site and also over many years in other lives, can clearly be seen in London Rd and environs. So many developments, so many missed opportunities to go with the flow and get some really good stuff - all 'in keeping - all deplorable.

Perhaps there may be some good news though. We noticed the sign on the historic P Galkoff's shop ...is it up for restoration? Would downtowners let us know if they have definite info about it?


Restoration in the pipeline? A reminder of when our garment district was a vibrant, bustling downtown district.

Big is Beautiful (and Better for You)
Speaking of Big Buildings (see below), look how the NHS is delivering 21st c. healthcare in London:

UCH London
University College Hospital

The stunning £422 million University College Hospital on Euston Road at 97m high should provide some pointers as to type of building -at the heart of the city - we should be developing for the Royal Liverpool University Hospital and Alder Hey Children's Hospital as part of the LIFT programme for Liverpool.

No Out Of Town Retail Please.

Letter of the week
Goes to W Backshall from Lydiate in the Echo this week!

Eyes -and Ears!
Suddenly, a crop of Liverpool pictures on the BBC's Picture of Britain website!
Go see

Tale of Two Cities
Much has been made over the past twenty years in the capital for various plans to convert Battersea Power Station. A recent article by Jonathan Glancey sheds new light on this amazing building where:

'"You could fit Trafalgar Square and St Paul's Cathedral inside, that's how big. Or you could sit 2.5 million people down to dinner'

Developer, Parkview International, has unveiled a £1.5bn redevelopment of this site.

But perhaps someone should give them a call because by strange coincidence the Tobacco Warehouse at Liverpool's Stanley Dock is just as big - with an identical 36 acre floorspace..

tobacco warehouse
The Tobacco Warehouse

Will the one benefit of WHS mean that this gargantuan Liverpudlan asset not be dropped and a viable development plan at last be found for the whole neighbourhood?

Just a load of bollards to us!
One of the very first issues that we raised with regards to taking a good downtown approach was the issue of pedestrianisation and zoning.

After the story about anti-car sympathies sneaking into the planning agenda icliverpool now highlight the absurd situation arising from a plethora of bollards around the 'retail' area.

De-pedestrianise the lot we say, it works fine in Paris and Rome! Traffic could then be restricted from a much greater area from 10a.m til 6p.m with management of deliveries, access for emergencies etc made much easier - and much more downtown friendly!

Well done to LDP&E for really upping the downtown approach in recent months too!

D-[Demolition] Day
With Liverpool City Council's executive board meeting this month to decide the fate of 460 homes adjacent to Princes Park - if demolition as part of the New Heartlands programme is approved, what assurances do we have of the quality of the replacement homes?

Will we get this or this?

[stop press: Cllrs decided not to recommend the demolition of this housing -Ed] see following piece:

New Heartlands
News that councillors have rejected outdated proposals for 'housing renewal' in the Welsh streets area is welcome. We can hope that this is the beginning of the realisation that the fundamental premise of our 'town planners' is utterly wrong, so every project is too ...or was it just political expedience?! Either way it proves that if you raise your voice, provide logical objections and rational alternatives you WILL BE HEARD .. let's hope!

RIP
Today we put aside this site's fiercely metro-centric stance and stand shoulder to shoulder with Londoners and with Britain against the terrorists. Click here to listen again to Mayor Livingstone's passionate and emotional eulogy for London in which he celebrates the liberalism, inclusivity and freedom of this [and all] great cities.

What about the workers?
Strange plans to revoke contract parking in council owned carparks that are usually taken by downtown workers, so as to 'free up' spaces
for tourists makes the mind boggle.


Liverpool Traffic

How about getting rid of some of the overwhelming amount of on street 'pay and display, double yellow lines in inappropriate locations and a little more imaginative use of vacant land for temporary parking provision till new car parks come on stream during - you've guessed it!

And as if to illustrate the point..
A small story in itself but a hugely
significant indication of how the city leaders have tied themselves in
contradictory knots: student retention,
micro-creative business support,
CAPITAL of culture etc.

And yet LIPA who wish to stop the flow of students leaving the city by providing
a nascent infrastrucure for creative growth look like having their plans for a £5m extension of their building rejected on the basis of the effect it might have on the neighbouring 'conservation area'.


An example of a nearby building to the 'conservation area'

Discuss?

Council[?] of Culture!
An excellent article on Cork, the European Capital of Culture 2004, in the Echo this week. And as one Cork citizen suggested:

'I'd say to the people of Liverpool 'If the official programme doesn't include anything which interests you, do it yourself!' Make it happen!"

Amen to That!

Internet radio, is that a FACT?
An interesting opportunity for budding DJ's and internet junkies takes place at FACT, in downtown Wood St, until Aug14th. Why not join the queues and have a go yourself?

Oh, but we just thought! (or the lunacy of expecting builders to put £10k buildings on £10m sites) Just another little consideration to throw into the development pot for downtown debate.

Real estate, land values, 'the market' are mainly just notional, based on and maintained by perceptions of what possible returns there are through investment that taps other aspects of confidence, i.e growth/tenents.

Land values are currently extremely high in Liverpool, one reason being the notion that the city is back in business. This can be wiped out in an instant - across the board - if there is no perception of there being a value then there is no value.

Now, maybe some (certainly not us) would see value in denying this sort of 'capitalist' way of things, but is this really what LCC want? Anyway, lots of public led schemes are dependant for financing and bringing in partners on the same 'notions' to bring projects on too. What will EP think when they take their Liverpool portfolio to the banks only to be told it's not worth a crap?

Cities do not work to the whims of aesthetes ...remember - you cannot buck the market, you can kill it, but you can't buck it!

Of cabbages and kings
Tony, 'Mr Manchester' Wilson is a life-long promoter and 'doer' on behalf of his city, Manchester. He has been an unstinting servant to that city, its creative community and the development of it's international profile with a clear thread that goes back to boyhood it seems.

He has passionately fought the cause for Manchester at every opportunity he has had during his professional life, even when not involved in a professional capacity ... he has a track record of 'Manc advocacy' that goes back a long, long, long way indeed ...

Mucho respect to Mr Manchester, a monika well earned, not self proclaimed, obviously no interloper.


INTERNATIONAL

Vienna's World Heritage Site will undoubtably be put under increased pressure with news that Jean Nouvel [very cool website], architect of the 142m Agbar Tower in Barcelona will be designing a new corporate HQ for Uniqa.

One thought - Nouvel is a world-class, world-famous, architect. Torre Agbar cost $37.5m, fills design magazines the world over - and has 32 floors.

torre agbar
credit: torreagbar.com

Beetham Tower, although welcome, cost $99m for the entire scheme (including the hotel) and has just 30 floors..

And whilst we love World Museum Liverpool [not very cool website..] for the £32 million of its refurbishment we could have had Peter Cook's incredible Kunsthaus Graz.

Six months after the Tsunami, people are still living in tin shacks and tents across Indonesia - if you haven't given already -please consider donating now?
www.dec.org.uk

Downtown Stockholm
The Swedish Capital offers some insight in how to promote its city both as a business and tourist destination.

stockholm waterfront
Credit: Stockholm Visitors Board
Photo: Christian KL Lagereek

A city of 760K people, with a great waterfront, it shares much in common with Liverpool. But when you consider Stockholm has 15 commercial radio stations, 1600 restaurants, 3600 shops, 88 cinemas and over 100 art galleries you realise just how far Liverpool has to go to maximise its downtown potential..

Independance Day
Some little reminders of Liverpool's unique bond with the US:

New York Liverpool connection:essay
Liverpool Confederacy
WWII GI's
British Consulate General NYC

New designs for New York's 9/11 memorial Freedom Tower were unveiled recently, but already depressingly bear the hallmarks of 'design by committee'. [Liverpudlians will know all about that one].

This revised design, based on Libeskind's orginal proposal has been slated in the US -and who did this new design? SOM - the very masterplanners of Liverpool's strategic regeneration framework: which gave birth to the Fourth Grace!

Sounds Familiar?
The New York Times comments on the number of city schemes which have failed ever since political power was wrested from them and passed to Albany -the State ('regional!') capital.

When the burghers of downtown Paris decided not to allow tall buildings in central Paris they developed a whole new district rather than give up on the commerce that is housed in skyscrapers... North of Chapel St for OUR La Defence ...or new Manhattan on the Mersey? Why Not?

 

July Reading

The Edifice Complex
Deyan Sudjic
Penguin
ISBN: 0713997621
Read Jonathan Glancy's review

City Room
Arthur Gelb
The life of Arthur Gelb as told against the backdrop of his career, from night copy-boy to managing editor at the New York Times. Gripping story of a city at the centre of unfolding world history.
Penguin
ISBN: 0-425-19831-6

London, and Robinson in Space
Patrick Keiller
*DVD* 1994, 1997
Patrick Keiller's imaginative and highly original two films each document a journey undertaken by the unseen 'researcher' Robinson and his similarly unseen companion.
British Film Institute

 

The Downtown Liverpool Organisation
info@downtownliverpool.org

46 Rodney Street, Liverpool L1 9AA UK

home about us enterprise development architecture design plus events site archive ideas central comment celebration  links